Page 7                                           Fall 1991

Juggling Defined Poetically

In reading some recent letters to the editor it seems that some people do not understand what juggling is. In "The Whys Of A Philosophical Scrivener," Martin Gardner cites an anonymous limerick about life. Substitute "juggling" for "life" and the limerick reads like this:

There was a young man of Cadiz

Who inferred that juggling is what it is,

For he early had learnt

If it were what it weren't

It could not be that which it is.

                                        

Roger Montandon, Bixby, Oklahoma

Magician Defends His Art

I take "sleight" offense at the statement in "The Academic Juggler" that, "Unlike magicians, who hide their skill, the juggler reveals all, yet still performs feats that, to the crowd, are incomprehensible."

 

By definition, magic is the art that conceals art in order to defy the laws of nature, creating an illusion. The author goes on to say, "It is magic without deceit, and in the stories individuals with such rare power (directly over objects and indirectly over minds) are capable of greatness."

 

Any "deceit" in the art of conjuring is used for the legitimate purpose of creating in the audience a feeling of awe, wonder, amazement and mystery. Albert Einstein wrote, "The most beautiful emotion that one can experience is that of the mysterious."

 

I love juggling as much as anyone, but also believe in calling a spade a spade. I think jugglers could use a wee bit more imagination, employ some of the same effects as magicians, and come up with some really good effects. Have fun!

 Manfred Losch Newark, New Jersey

 

The Academic Juggler's author, Arthur Lewbel, responds: "It was not my intention to insult magicians, but rather to observe that juggling can generate the same sense of awe and wonder without trickery, and that this is a valuable goal for performers to strive for by whatever means. "    

<--- Previous Page

Return to Main Index

Next Page --->